Tuesday, 05 November 2024 04:50

Editorial: The Derivation dilemma in the Tax Reform Bills

Rate this item
(0 votes)

The current controversy surrounding the Tax Reform Bills introduced by President Bola Tinubu highlights a significant and contentious issue: the principle of derivation in the proposed Value Added Tax (VAT) sharing formula. At the heart of the matter is a proposed increase in the derivation percentage from 20% to 60% for VAT revenues, a move that has ignited fervent opposition, particularly from Northern political leaders. Their concerns raise critical questions about equity, regional balance, and the historical context of Nigeria’s fiscal policies.

Historically, the derivation principle has undergone significant transformations. Initially, during the colonial period, regions retained 100% of mineral revenues, reflecting a decentralized approach to resource management. This shifted over time, with military regimes imposing increasingly restrictive allocations that often undermined the autonomy of resource-rich states. The introduction of the 13% minimum derivation formula in the 1999 Constitution was a hard-won concession for oil-producing states, primarily in the Niger Delta, which have long fought for a fair share of the wealth extracted from their lands.

The proposed changes in the VAT sharing formula, however, threaten to exacerbate existing regional tensions. By allocating 60% of VAT based on derivation—essentially rewarding states based on their consumption rather than production—President Tinubu’s reforms seem to favor states like Lagos and Rivers, which are more consumption-oriented. This raises valid concerns about perceived bias in a governance structure already fraught with accusations of favoritism.

The Northern Governors’ Forum’s swift rejection of the tax bills stems from fears that such a significant increase in derivation will only deepen disparities between regions, favoring the South while marginalizing the North.

Equity demands that if the government considers increasing derivation for VAT, similar adjustments should be made across all revenue sources, including mineral resources and Company Income Tax. The current proposal appears selective and risks entrenching regional disparities rather than alleviating them. It is not just about the allocation of VAT but about setting a precedent for how fiscal policies are crafted in a country marked by diversity and regional inequalities.

Furthermore, the historical context of the derivation principle underscores the need for a balanced approach. The gradual decline of derivation percentages from the colonial era to the present has created a landscape where resource-rich states often feel shortchanged, while less resource-endowed states depend heavily on federal allocations. A re-evaluation of how revenues are shared, grounded in the principle of derivation, should consider the historical injustices faced by various regions and strive for a fairer distribution of resources.

The ongoing debates surrounding these tax reform bills are not merely about percentages; they encapsulate the broader struggle for equity and justice within Nigeria’s federal system. If President Tinubu’s administration seeks to build a truly united Nigeria, it must address these disparities with transparency and inclusiveness, ensuring that all states benefit from the nation’s collective wealth, rather than a select few. The challenge lies in crafting a fiscal policy that honors the principle of derivation while promoting a sense of shared destiny among all Nigerians. Only then can Nigeria’s social formations hope to move past regional grievances and build a more equitable future for the country.

March 30, 2025

Foreign investment in Nigerian equities market declined 30% in February

Foreign investment inflows to Nigeria's equities market dropped by 29.66% in February 2025, falling to…
March 26, 2025

Afenifere condemns emergency rule in Rivers, announces burial plans for late leader Ayo Adebanjo

The Pan-Yoruba socio-political organization, Afenifere, has strongly condemned the declaration of a state of emergency…
March 30, 2025

Does wearing a cap make you go bald? Here’s what dermatologists want you to know about hair loss

Hair loss can be an upsetting and worrisome experience. But with a slew of wellness…
March 30, 2025

Two 'proof of heaven' stories and one 'proof of hell' that had atheist calling out…

Ole Braatelien What happens to our consciousness the moment we die? Christians believe our souls…
March 28, 2025

Terrorists kill 16 on army base, military outpost in Borno, security sources say

Suspected Islamist fighters launched a coordinated attack on an army base and a military outpost…
March 30, 2025

Here’s the latest as Israel-Hamas war enters Day 541

Hamas agrees to Gaza ceasefire proposal, the group's chief says Hamas has agreed to a…
March 28, 2025

Bill Gates: Within 10 years, AI will replace many doctors and teachers—humans won’t be needed…

Tom Huddleston Jr. Over the next decade, advances in artificial intelligence will mean that humans…
January 08, 2025

NFF appoints new Super Eagles head coach

The Nigeria Football Federation (NFF) has appointed Éric Sékou Chelle as the new Head Coach…

NEWSSCROLL TEAM: 'Sina Kawonise: Publisher/Editor-in-Chief; Afolabi Ajibola: IT Manager;
Contact Us: [email protected] Tel/WhatsApp: +234 811 395 4049

Copyright © 2015 - 2025 NewsScroll. All rights reserved.