Friday, 15 November 2024 12:27

Supreme Court dismisses suit by 19 states against legality of EFCC, ICPC, others. Here’s what the landmark ruling means

Rate this item
(0 votes)

Overview of the Ruling

The Supreme Court of Nigeria has delivered a landmark judgment dismissing a challenge by 19 state governments against the constitutional validity of federal anti-corruption agencies - the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Independent Corrupt Practices Commission (ICPC), and Nigerian Financial Intelligence Unit (NFIU).

Key Legal and Constitutional Issues

The States' Arguments

1. Constitutional Challenge

   - The states argued that the establishment of these agencies violated Nigeria's federal structure

   - They cited a 2004 Supreme Court precedent requiring international conventions to receive majority approval from state assemblies

   - The argument centered on the UN Convention against Corruption, which influenced the EFCC Act

The Court's Response

1. Constitutional Validity

   - The Court upheld the federal government's authority to establish anti-corruption agencies

   - Reaffirmed that state laws cannot override federal legislation in this domain

   - Referenced existing precedent (AG Ondo v. AG Federation) supporting federal anti-corruption powers

Implications for Nigerian Federalism

Balance of Power

1. Federal Supremacy

   - The ruling strengthens federal oversight of corruption matters

   - Establishes clear hierarchical relationship between federal and state anti-corruption laws

   - Reinforces the principle that states cannot legislate to diminish federal anti-corruption powers

2. State Authority

   - While states retain legislative powers, these must align with federal anti-corruption frameworks

   - The ruling limits states' ability to shield officials from federal investigation

   - Creates a more unified approach to fighting corruption

Impact on Anti-Corruption Efforts

Strengthened Framework

1. Institutional Authority

   - Validates and protects the operational mandate of EFCC, ICPC, and NFIU

   - Removes legal uncertainty about their investigative powers

   - Prevents potential balkanization of anti-corruption efforts

2. Political Implications

   - The Court's characterization of the suit as "selfish" sends a strong message

   - Demonstrates judicial support for centralized anti-corruption efforts

   - May deter future attempts to weaken federal anti-corruption agencies

Notable Political Fallout

1. Internal State Discord

   - Benue State's suspension of its Attorney General highlights political sensitivities

   - Multiple states withdrew from the suit, suggesting shifting political calculations

   - Reveals tensions between state executives and their legal officers

Conclusion

The Supreme Court's ruling represents a significant victory for Nigeria's anti-corruption framework. By dismissing the states' challenge and explicitly rebuking attempts to weaken federal oversight, the Court has:

- Reinforced the federal government's constitutional authority to fight corruption

- Protected the operational independence of anti-corruption agencies

- Demonstrated judicial commitment to maintaining strong anti-corruption mechanisms

- Created a clearer legal framework for federal-state cooperation in fighting corruption

The judgment strikes a balance between federalism and the need for coordinated anti-corruption efforts, ultimately strengthening Nigeria's institutional capacity to combat corruption.

January 13, 2025

Fuel prices in Nigeria likely to surge as Brent crude rises above $81

Fuel prices in Nigeria are expected to climb further as Brent crude prices surged above…
January 11, 2025

Ohanaeze Ndigbo gets new President-General

John Azuta-Mbata, a former senator, has been elected as the new president-general of Ohanaeze Ndigbo,…
January 12, 2025

Why some animals appear to mourn their dead

Grief has long thought to be a human trait, but other animals – from killer…
January 04, 2025

Shy man cuts off 4 fingers instead of telling boss he wanted to quit his…

A 32-year-old Indian man admitted to cutting off four fingers on his left hand to…
January 13, 2025

Bandits attack Zamfara mosque, kidnap dozens of worshippers

Armed assailants launched an attack on a mosque in Birnin Yaro village, Zamfara state, kidnapping…
January 13, 2025

What to know after Day 1054 of Russia-Ukraine war

RUSSIAN PERSPECTIVE Ukraine won’t reclaim all Russian-held territories – Trump adviser It is not possible…
December 25, 2024

Stem cell therapy to correct heart failure in children could 'transform lives'

Renowned visionary English physician William Harvey wrote in 1651 about how our blood contains all…
January 08, 2025

NFF appoints new Super Eagles head coach

The Nigeria Football Federation (NFF) has appointed Éric Sékou Chelle as the new Head Coach…

NEWSSCROLL TEAM: 'Sina Kawonise: Publisher/Editor-in-Chief; Prof Wale Are Olaitan: Editorial Consultant; Femi Kawonise: Head, Production & Administration; Afolabi Ajibola: IT Manager;
Contact Us: [email protected] Tel/WhatsApp: +234 811 395 4049

Copyright © 2015 - 2025 NewsScroll. All rights reserved.