“Every morning a lion wakes up, it knows it must run faster than the slowest gazelle, or it will starve to death…It doesn’t matter whether you are a lion or a gazelle, you better be running.”

First attributed to Dan Montano in The Economist, but popularised by Thomas Friedman in The World is Flat.

If, 20 years ago, you asked me whether big technology (or big tech) companies were a threat to journalism, my answer would have been an emphatic yes. After all, these companies do our job without our job description. They also disrupt the media space while taking little responsibility for content.

Perhaps I should explain that there is a slight difference in form, but not always in substance, between big tech and big search engines.

While big tech could sometimes be a dominant player in information technology hardware, like Samsung, or in e-commerce, like Amazon, search engines are software monsters although both core hardware and software providers in this field have the capacity as we have seen, for forward or backward linkages. I will focus more on search engines, at least a few in the big league that have significantly disrupted our work, for good or ill.

I’m sure you know them – Google, Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), Yahoo, YouTube, Baidu and so on. Please don’t add MySpace to this list; it died before they could write our obituary.

The buzz-word these days, is “sustainability.” What does it mean? One of the most practical definitions I have seen is, “sustainability consists of fulfilling the needs of the current generation without compromising the needs of future generations.”

As to whether big tech poses an existential threat to the survival of the Nigerian media and the way out, if indeed such a threat exists, we shall see soon enough.

How media earns

Traditional media’s two basic sources of revenue are advertising and circulation or subscription sales. On the face of it, the fear of a journalistic doomsday appears justified in light of catastrophic declines in revenues from these two major sources of media income.

The relationship between big tech and traditional news media is already complex enough. But I can assure you that the impact of big tech on the media as we know it is just beginning. The Reuters Institute has already predicted this year to be the breakthrough year for artificial intelligence and its application for journalism.

The institute rightly said the arrival of ChatGPT has transformed the debate over whether AI is here to stay or not. In its journal, Journalism, Media, and Technology Trends and Predictions 2023, the Institute said about ChatGPT, “Its speed and capabilities are awe-inspiring and frightening at the same time. While the underlying models have been around for some time, ChatGPT has turned these into an accessible prototype that gives a real sense of where AI may be heading. It can tell jokes (but has been trained not to tell racist or sexist ones), come up with plots for a film or book, write computer code.”

In case you missed it, AI even mocked our industry in the report by summarising the challenges facing local news media in 50 words!  Here’s the Q&A:

“NI: Can you summarise the challenges facing local media in 50 words.

ChatGPT: The challenges facing local media include the decline of print media and advertising revenues, competition from online news sources, and the impact of Covid-19 pandemic on local businesses, which are the major sources of advertising revenue. These challenges have made it difficult for local news outlets to sustain their operations and continue to provide important coverage and information to their communities.”

More news outlets, including News24 of South Africa, are training their systems with the voices of their popular anchors with astonishing accuracy.

Big Tech: Archenemy, Frenemy, or Friend?

Big tech may be playing more actively in our industry than us, taking an increasing share of our money and maybe our jobs without being responsible – both in proprietorship and accountability – for the information it disseminates. It has exploited its unmatched reach, ability to use algorithms to tailor content to suit consumers, and real-time engagement advantage to retain consumers. But as they say, there are two sides to a coin.

Positive Impact:

1. Increased Exposure:

• Big tech platforms provide news media companies with a vast audience. Articles and videos can be shared and spread rapidly on these platforms, leading to increased visibility and traffic for news outlets.

2. New Revenue Streams:

• Some tech platforms have revenue-sharing agreements with news media companies. For example, YouTube shares ad revenue with news organisations that post videos on its platform, once you reach a certain threshold.

3. Better Analytics:

• Tech platforms provide news media companies with sophisticated analytic tools that allow them to better understand their audiences and tailor content to user preferences.

4. Engagement Opportunities:

• Social media platforms allow news outlets to interact with their audience in a way that wasn’t possible before. They can receive immediate feedback, address concerns, and build communities around their content.

Negative Impact:

1. Ad Revenue Competition:

• Big tech companies have diverted advertising revenues away from traditional media outlets. They offer targeted advertising based on vast amounts of data, which is often more appealing to advertisers. I was scandalised during the recent general elections in Nigeria that folks who had built their careers in the mainstream and whom we were banking on left us high and dry, with the excuse that their principals wanted minimum use of legacy media platforms! But I understood, even if I did so with a heavy heart! Why? A BBC online report www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zd9bd6f/revision/7 said, “Politicians are investing heavily in the use of websites, blogs, podcasts and social networking websites like Facebook and Twitter as a way of reaching voters.”

“During the 2019 election campaign,” the BBC report continued, “the Conservatives spent one million pounds on Facebook alone, at a point, running 2,500 adverts.”

Let’s look at some more numbers: Google earned about $3bn from sales to China-based advertisers in 2018; Google UK earned £3.34bn in 18 months ending December 2021 as total revenue in the UK market; in 2022 Google’s share of UK digital advert market was 38 percent of all adverts valued at £5.72bn.

If the UK media is complaining, I’ll advise they should not do so as loudly as us. Why?  I’m sure most of you already know that on revenue from traffic, for example, while you can get as much as $2 in CPM from traffic from the UK or the US, the best you can hope to get from local traffic, that is, traffic from Nigeria regardless of the size, is probably 80cents per 1000! Sure, this example is related to revenue from traffic; but the ratio, even for advertising is not significantly different.

2. Spread of Misinformation:

• The ease of sharing on social media platforms can contribute to the spread of misinformation. This not only misleads the public but also undermines trust in news media.

3. Algorithmic Control:

• The algorithms used by tech platforms control what content is seen and what is buried. This can lead to a loss of control for news media over how and to whom their content is distributed. In an article by Kanchan Srivastava, published on February 27, 2023, entitled, “Surviving the algorithm: News publishers walk the tightrope as Google ‘updates’ hit hard,” the author quoted a respondent as saying, “Google has released major algo updates in 2022, which impacted search traffic across publishers.” Publishers didn’t find two major updates last year by the big tech funny at all.

4. Dependency:

• News media companies may become dependent on these platforms for traffic and revenue, which can be risky given the changing algorithms and policies.

5. Potential for Censorship:

• Big tech companies have the power to censor or prioritise certain types of news content based on their own policies or external pressures, which can impact the democratic discourse.

6. Data Privacy Concerns:

• There are concerns about how big tech companies handle user data, and these concerns extend to the partnerships between tech platforms and news media companies.

7. Dilution of Brand Identity:

• Being lumped together with a multitude of other content producers on a single platform can dilute a news outlet’s brand identity.

    8. Room for redress

    • Complaints about discriminatory business or editorial practices from Nigeria and a number other developing countries are hardly treated with seriousness

All About Algorithm, the Devil?

Not all the challenges summarised by AI were brought upon the traditional media by big tech. Nor are we here solely because of Google’s malicious fiddling with its algo. We in the traditional media space share in the blame for what took our industry from distress to life support.

I will tweak HBS Clayton Christensen a bit by saying for a long time, we were innovating our products in response to technological shifts, with very little attention to our business models, or if you’ll pardon my drift, what E. Jerome McCarthy described in his book, Basic Marketing: A Managerial Approach,as the 7Ps of marketing – Product, Promotion, Price, Place, People, Process and Physical Evidence.

Nothing depicts this more tellingly than media organisations’ need to reconsider obsolete editorial culture and imbibe new ones, especially in the areas of collaboration, audience-centered production, and creating an audience community.

To be able to compete favourably, media houses may have to take another look at the redundancy levels in-house. Reuters Institute predicted that more newspapers would stop daily print production due to rising print costs and the weakening of distribution networks. It also predicted a further spate of venerable titles switching to an online-only model. They are happening before our own eyes.

Let me be local. In LEADERSHIP the average production costs of our major consumables – newsprint, plates, ink, energy – have risen, with the most significant rise being in energy cost, which increased by 40 percent in one year, while our advert rates have remained largely constant.

Survival in the media industry used to depend on rivalry in the media; now it depends on collaboration. Recent collaborative works on the Pandora Papers, BureauLocal, and the #CoronaVirusFacts have shown that media organisations can work with colleagues across boundaries to share resources for the common good.

In 2020, Aliaa El-Shabassy, a teaching assistant at Cairo University, listed six reader needs outlined by the BBC for media organisations that want to stay ahead and compete with tech platforms. Why should other media companies listen to the BBC’s advice? Well, its global reach in 2020 was 468.2m people a week!

El-Shabassy wrote, “During Corona's peak when audiences needed a trustworthy source to rely on, BBC News scored the highest reach among other international media organisations. Moreover, according to the annual Global Audience Measure, a total of 151 million users per week are accessing BBC's news and entertainment content digitally.”

Six reader needs that any Media Practitioner must be aware of, according to the BBC are:

Update me – which means in the era of information overload, your audience should know in a new light what they already know about.  

Give me perspective – it is a newsroom's own goal to believe that perspective can only be shaped by the newsroom. Your audience can provide perspective.    

Educate me – everyone wants to learn about an exciting new thing. Once you provide diverse content with curiosity value, your audience will be eager to find more from you.

Keep me on trend – audiences want to be kept trending. Perhaps that was why the BBC reached a record number of people during Covid-19.

Amuse me – one of the reasons tech platforms prioritise user-generated content (remember Facebook’s pivot to video) over professionally produced content is that they have better entertainment value to attract adverts. The simple truth is that if you make your audience smile, they will most likely come back. It doesn’t always have to be serious! The more entertaining yet informative your content is, the more your institution is likely to grow.

Inspire me – inspiring stories attract younger audiences more than others and younger audiences source content through tech platforms more. Do the math!

Big Stick for Big Tech

Yet, big tech can’t get off lightly. In 2021, and despite heavy criticism, the Australian government pioneered a new media bargaining code that compels tech platforms to negotiate payment to local news media outlets for using their content.

Initially criticised as a form of subsidy from big tech to big media, significantly because of the role played by media mogul Rupert Murdoch, the law has been hugely successful. Both big and small media outlets have benefitted from the law while the country’s journalism practice has also been revitalised, leading to the creation of new journalism jobs.

In an article published in 2022 by Brookings, Courtney Radsch, Fellow, Institute for Technology, Law and Policy, UCLA, wrote that Australia’s big tech regulatory efforts were developed around three thrusts: taxation, competition/antitrust, and intellectual property.

The bargaining code therefore allows publishers to collectively bargain without violating antitrust laws; requires tech platforms to negotiate with publishers for the use of news snippets; also requires them to pay licensing fees to publishers; and taxes digital advertising and uses the revenue to subsidise news outlets.    

The EU, US and India have since adopted their own media bargaining code and the idea of compelling big tech to pay for news they don’t produce but use and sell is gaining momentum, has been gaining global support since Australia took the bull by the horns.

I’m aware that the Newspaper Proprietor’s Association of Nigeria (NPAN) set up a committee in July to examine the possibility of collective bargaining with big tech.

Staying in business

Understanding that consumers hold all – or most – of the aces, is the first step towards sustainability. For perspective, a paper entitled, “The Newspaper: Emerging Trends, Opportunities, and Strategies for Survival and Sustainability,” by Frank Aigbogun presented at a retreat for NPAN on July 18, 2023, said between 2010 and 2015, audience time spent spend on online media consumption soared to 150%. In that time, audience time spent on television decreased to -8%; radio, -15%; magazine, -23%; and newspaper, -31%.

The reality of digital media is that evolution has brought about new competition and fresh opportunities. Solutions journalism, citizens journalism, and a deeper interface between journalism and technology are the order of the day. There was a time when we consumed music via turntables, stereos with records, and then cassettes and then compact discs. Album sales are no longer used to measure the success of a body of work.

Now it is streaming, the playground of big tech companies such as Apple Music, Spotify, Amazon Music, TIDAL, Pandora, etc. If technology did not pose an existential threat to the music industry, I do not think big tech would end journalism.

Reuters Institute said, “Better data connections have opened up possibilities beyond just text and pictures and smartphone adoption has accelerated the use of visual journalism, vertical video, and podcasts.”

Good content should not be free. What technology is doing, therefore, is to offer traditional media the opportunity to reach more people and make a profit.

Through the use of content and tech-led innovation, a growing list of brands are expanding into broadcast and streaming TV to grow and engage their audiences, and bring in new revenue streams. This involves the use of new formats, new technology, and new products to broaden and retain the audience base.

In addition, feedback tools, such as engagement matrices, are being used to “galvanise the industry on loyalty” (according to the Financial Times, which now uses the RFV – Recency, Frequency, and Volume of reading its digital content).

Traditional media organisations in Nigeria also need to rethink their business models, from content to distribution and personnel costs. One of the ways some media organisations are going about change in business model is by targeting niche markets, while others invest in research, education and learning.

Other ideas you may find useful in turning an existential threat to an opportunity for sustainable growth, are:

● Diversify: Think about Julius Berger now into massive production and export of cashew nuts! Think about games, films, books, special events & publications, etc

● Preserve your candle: Don’t give content free and still not collect and deploy customer data. Know your audiences and cultivate them

● Re-purpose content

● Review your systems and processes regularly and take tough decisions

● Be ethical

● Invest in talent

Keep running!

Let me return to the first sentence of this presentation. Yes, big tech poses a threat because of the opaque relationship it has with traditional media. However, is this threat going to pull the plug on journalism? I’ll say no. I’ll be the first to admit that the prevailing mood in the media industry is one of uncertainty.

To be certain, nothing will bring back the days when advertisement and circulation were enough to successfully run a media organisation. Also, because the media is a kind of cultural sector that does not necessarily respond to the principles of demand and supply, media organisations that fail to swim with the tide will continue to struggle or pack up altogether. If we invest in what feels relevant and useful to consumers, then we have nothing to worry about because technology will help us know exactly how to adapt and reach our target audience.

What we should worry about instead is how to retain the ethics of our practice in the face of robotic and artificial media which might just overpower the audiences we share.

Remember: whether you’re a lion or a gazelle, you better be running!

** Ishiekwene is the Editor-In-Chief of LEADERSHIP. This is a slightly modified version of the paper he presented at the 19th All Nigeria Editors Conference (ANEC) at the Akwa Ibom Hotel & Gold Resort, Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, on Wednesday, November 15, 2023

On the second floor of the Latyfah hair salon in Dakar, brushes, hairdryers and scissors were in constant motion. Sitting amidst bags full of wigs, owner Awa Ndao checked the finishing touches before handing over the precious locks to the delivery men, while glancing at the video surveillance screens set up in the middle of the room. In recent weeks, the store has been undergoing security upgrades, after thieves recently tried to gain entry in the middle of the night. "Burglars took about 30 wigs, computers and perfumes three years ago. More than 20 million CFA francs [€30,500] were taken," explained the company manager.

"We only use quality natural human hair, which is very expensive," explained Ndao, who has been in the business for over 30 years. Nicknamed the "queen of small heads" for her famous short styles, the hairdresser sells wigs that cost from 75,000 (€100) to several hundred thousand CFA francs, depending on the cut, density, texture, length and material of the hair.

She has a flourishing business as wigs resist the "nappy" trend – a contraction of "natural" and "happy" – which aims to rehabilitate natural African hair. As the holiday season approaches, orders from Senegalese women explode, and these "locks of gold" equally attract increasing numbers of thieves. The wigs are often resold on the black market, or on social media, at a much more affordable price than their initial value. On the street, thieves sometimes prefer them to telephones or handbags.

'Customers can keep them for up to 10 years'

In Dakar, women are no longer safe from having their wigs snatched. Nogaye Sidy Fall, 42, had this bitter experience in September 2022. She was shopping in the popular Colobane market, on the eve of the start of the new school year. "Suddenly I felt my wig was gone. It was made of natural hair, and I had paid nearly 300,000 CFA francs [€400] for it," she said.

She had bought it a week earlier but hadn't dared tell her husband the price. So she preferred to tell him that it was made of synthetic hair – which is much more affordable – and that there was no point in going to the police with a complaint. "I don't have the luxury of buying such valuable wigs every year," explained the mother of one. In her cupboards, she keeps two other quality hairpieces worth 150,000 and 200,000 CFA.

Adji (who prefers to remain anonymous) had her wig ripped off her head by teenagers on scooters as she got off the bus on her way to work. It was a bobbed curly haircut she'd just treated herself to. "I'll have to wait a long time before I can afford a new one of the same quality," she said, sadly. It's all the more ironic as she works at Enera Beauty, one of the capital's most renowned hair salons for its natural hair wigs.

"We import human hair from Vietnam at 200,000 CFA a kilo, and it's treated without chemicals," explained business owner Arène Khouma, who opened her salon in Dakar's Ouest Foire neighborhood in 2017. Each month, she imports between 5 and 10 kilograms of hair – 30 kilograms in the holiday months. At Enera Beauty, wigs cost 165,000 to 400,000 CFA francs. "Customers can keep them for 10 years with the right care," she explained. "We don't do mass production, we customize all our products because every customer has a different head. That explains the price."

Difficult-to-solve cases

Most salons import their wigs from China or India, where the locks are collected in temples when worshippers shave their heads as religious offerings. These countries have become the world's biggest suppliers of human hair with 2,383 tonnes exported in 2022, an increase of 66% between 2018 and 2022. In Senegal, the value of imports of "feathers, artificial flowers and hair" rose from 145 million to 286 million CFA francs between 2017 and 2021, according to the Agence Nationale de la Statistique et de la Démographie (National Agency for Statistics and Demographics, ANSD).

The Senegalese police are now dealing with multiple cases of hair theft. In September, following a complaint from a victim who had recognized on TikTok the wig plucked from her head a few days earlier, the thieves were arrested. They were in possession of 91 second-hand wigs and were sentenced to three months in prison, with 21 months suspended.

Nevertheless, these cases are difficult to resolve. Despite the CCTV footage delivered to the police when he filed a complaint, Melchisedek Ibrahima, manager of the Perles Hair salon in Dakar's Ouakam neighborhood, has never been able to identify the thieves who targeted him. "On Sunday, July 24, 2022, at around 6 am, neighbors called me because the windows were broken. When I arrived, all the mannequins' heads in my store were naked, the stock had disappeared. We estimated the damage at 14 million CFA [€21,400]," said Ibrahima.

A year and a half later, the store's shelves, decorated with artificial flowers, were once again filled with wigs of all colors and lengths. "We had to start from scratch. But we've stepped up security by hiring a security company," continued the salon manager. "It's all worth it, because, as his colleague Khouma puts it, "a wig salon is now like a jewelry store."

Le Monde

Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) and Trade Union Congress (TUC) have suspended the nationwide strike they embarked on Tuesday. 

The suspension of the strike came after leaders of the two unions met with representatives of the federal government in a meeting on Wednesday at the office of the national security adviser (NSA).

At the end of the meeting, the labour unions agreed to consult with their members on the next step concerning the nationwide strike.

The federal government was represented at the meeting by Simon Lalong, minister of labour and employment; Nkeiruka Onyeajeocha, minister of state for labour and employment, and Nuhu Ribadu, the NSA.

The unions were represented by Festus Usifo, president of TUC;  Emmanuel Ugboaja, general secretary of NLC and other labour leaders.

Speaking to journalists at the end of the sitdown, the TUC president said they had a robust discussion with the federal government’s team.

The labour leaders said they received a commitment from the Ribadu-led meeting that those arrested for the physical assault on Ajaero would be prosecuted.

The nationwide strike is a protest against the alleged brutality of Joe Ajaero, president of NLC,  in Imo state.

Ajaero was reportedly picked up from the Imo council secretariat of the congress in Owerri by heavily armed police officers.

However, the Imo police command said Ajaero was not arrested but was taken into protective custody to avoid being lynched by a mob.

On November 5, the national industrial court in Owerri, the capital of Imo, issued an order restraining labour unions from embarking on a strike in the state.

Also, the federal government secured an order restraining the unions and their affiliates from embarking on the strike.

Despite the court orders, the labour unions stood their ground and proceeded with the strike.

Nuhu Ribadu, the NSA, had begged the unions to call off the strike, adding that the attackers of Ajaero, had been arrested.

The Cable

Nigeria’s headline inflation rate for October 2023 has increased to 27.33 percent, the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) has disclosed.

The figure is 0.9 short of the 28.2 percent recorded 18 years ago, in August 2005.

The NBS in a report released on Wednesday said, on a year-on-year basis, the headline inflation rate was 6.24 points points higher compared to the rate recorded in October 2022, which was (21.09 percent).

“The increase in the headline index for October 2023 was attributed to the increase in some items in the basket of goods and services at the divisional level.

“These increases were observed in Food and non-alcoholic Beverages (14.16%), Housing, Water, Electricity, Gas & other Fuel (4.57%), Clothing & Footwear (2.09%), Transport (1.78%), Furnishings & Household Equipment and maintenance (1.37%), Education (1.08%) and Health (0.82%). Others are Miscellaneous Goods & Services (0.45%), Restaurants & Hotels (0.33%), Alcoholic Beverages, Tobacco & Kola (0.30%), Recreation & Culture (0.19%) and Communication (0.19).”

Similarly, it said food sub-index for October 2023 increased to 31.52% on a year-on-year basis, which was 7.80% points higher compared to the rate recorded in October 2022 (23.72%).

It said the rise in food inflation was due to increases in prices of bread & cereals, oil & fat, potatoes, yam and other tubers, fish, fruit, meat, vegetables and milk, cheese, and eggs.

“However, on a month-on-month basis, the Food inflation rate in October 2023 was 1.91%. This was 0.54% lower compared to the rate recorded in September 2023 (2.45%). The decline in food inflation was caused by a decrease in the average prices of Fruits, oil and fat, coffee, tea and cocoa, bread and cereals.”

Daily Trust

A former minister of finance, Onaolapo Soleye, is dead.

Soleye died on Wednesday at a private hospital in Abeokuta, the capital of his home Ogun state. He was aged 90.

He was the finance minister under the military regime of Muhammadu Buhari from 1984 to 1985.

He had earlier served as commissioner for works in Ogun State.

Soleye’s family, in a statement on Wednesday, said he passed away four days after celebrating his 90th birthday on Saturday.

‘With heavy hearts but with gratitude to God Almighty for a long, impactful and positively eventful life, the family announces the passing of Pa Onaolapo Soleye, the father of our late brother, Maj Gen OO Soleye (retd.). He turned 90 years only last Saturday’, the statement reads.

“Papa served the country and humanity in various capacities rising to the position of an Associate Professor in the University of Ibadan, Commissioner for Works in Ogun State and Minister of Finance of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, among others’.

“He was a true lover of God and humanity and this translated into his unwavering commitment to church activities as well as ready support and assistance to all who came across him, in any way that he could’, the family said.

“The loss of Soleye is surely not that of the Soleye family alone. It’s our father that has just passed and we must all prepare to be part of his rites of passage.

“Burial details will be announced by the family in due course. Until then, please pray for the repose of Papa’s soul and God’s comfort upon his family and other loved ones.”

PT

Israel searches for traces of Hamas in raid of key Gaza hospital packed with patients

Israeli troops on Wednesday stormed into Gaza’s largest hospital, searching for traces of Hamas inside and beneath the facility, where newborns and hundreds of other patients have suffered for days without electricity and other basic necessities. The forces also pressed on with their wider ground offensive.

Details from the daylong raid remained sketchy, but officials from Israel and Gaza presented different accounts of what was happening at Shifa Hospital in Gaza City: The Israeli army released video showing soldiers carrying boxes labeled as “baby food” and “medical supplies,” while health officials talked of terrified staff and patients as troops moved through the buildings.

After encircling Shifa for days, Israel faced pressure to prove its claim that Hamas had turned the hospital into a command center and used patients, staff and civilians sheltering there to provide cover for its militants. The allegation is part of Israel’s broader accusation that Hamas uses Palestinians as human shields. Israel released video late Wednesday of weapons it said it found in one building, but so far its search showed no signs of tunnels or a sophisticated command center.

Hamas and Gaza health officials deny militants operate in Shifa — a hospital that employs some 1,500 people and has more than 500 beds, according to the Palestinian news agency. Palestinians and rights groups say Israel has recklessly endangered civilians as it seeks to eradicate Hamas.

As Israel tightens its hold on northern Gaza, leaders have talked of expanding the ground operation into the south to root out Hamas. Most of Gaza’s 2.3 million people have already crowded into the territory’s south, where a worsening fuel shortage threatens to paralyze the delivery of humanitarian services and shut down mobile phone and internet service.

The war between Israel and Hamas erupted after the militant group killed some 1,200 people and seized around 240 captives in an Oct. 7 attack that shattered Israelis’ sense of security.

Israeli airstrikes have since killed more than 11,200 people, two-thirds of them women and minors, according to the Palestinian Health Ministry in Ramallah, which coordinates with the ministry branch in Hamas-ruled Gaza. Another 2,700 have been reported missing, with most believed to be buried under the rubble. The ministry’s count does not differentiate between civilian and militant deaths.

ISRAELI RAID INTO SHIFA

Israeli forces launched their raid into the large Shifa compound around 2 a.m. and remained on the grounds after nightfall Wednesday, with tanks stationed outside and snipers on nearby buildings, Munir al-Boursh, a senior official with Gaza’s Health Ministry inside the hospital, told The Associated Press. It was not possible to independently assess the situation inside.

Al-Boursh said that for hours, the troops ransacked the basement and other buildings, including those housing the emergency and surgery departments, and searched the grounds for tunnels. Troops questioned and face-screened patients, staff and people sheltering in the facility, he said, adding that he did not know if any were detained.

“Patients, women and children are terrified,” he told the AP by phone.

Neither the Palestinians nor the military reported any clashes inside the hospital. The military said its troops killed four militants outside the hospital at the start of the operation. Throughout days of fighting in the surrounding streets in previous days, there were no reports of militants firing from inside Shifa.

The Israeli military said it was carrying out a “precise and targeted operation against Hamas in a specified area in the hospital,” and that its soldiers were accompanied by medical teams bringing in incubators and other supplies.

It added that forces were also searching for hostages. The plight of the captives, who include men, women and children, has galvanized Israeli support for the war. Families and supporters of the hostages are holding a protest march from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.

The video released by the military from inside Shifa showed three duffel bags it said it found hidden around an MRI lab, each containing an assault rifle, grenades and Hamas uniforms, as well as a closet that contained a number of assault rifles without ammunition clips. A laptop was also discovered and taken for study. The AP could not independently verify the Israeli claims that the weapons were found inside the hospital.

“These weapons have absolutely no business being inside a hospital,” Jonathan Conricus, a military spokesman, said in the video, adding that he believed the material was “just the top of the iceberg.” The military said the search was continuing, but it did not immediately show any sign of tunnels or an extensive military center.

The raid drew condemnation from the U.N., Jordan and the West Bank’s Palestinian Authority, which called it a violation of international law. Separately, the U.N. Security Council approved a resolution calling for “humanitarian pauses and corridors” throughout Gaza after four failed attempts to respond to the Israel-Hamas war.

In other developments, U.S. President Joe Biden said he believes the war will stop only when Hamas’ ability to kill and injure Israelis is degraded. He also said he urged Israel to exercise caution in its military operations at the hospital.

“I think it’s going to stop when Hamas no longer maintains the capacity to murder,” Biden said after meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperative conference in California.

Biden said he discussed with Israelis their need to “be incredibly careful” as they worked to clear the hospital.

At one point, tens of thousands of Palestinians fleeing Israeli bombardment were sheltering at the hospital, but most left in recent days as the fighting drew closer. The fate of premature babies at the hospital has drawn particular concern.

The Health Ministry said 40 patients, including three babies, have died since Shifa’s emergency generator ran out of fuel Saturday.

There was no immediate word on the condition of another 36 babies the ministry said earlier were at risk of dying because there is no power for incubators.

Hours before Israel’s raid, the United States said its own intelligence indicated militants have used Shifa and other hospitals — and tunnels beneath them — to support military operations and hold hostages.

Under international humanitarian law, hospitals can lose their protected status if combatants use them for military purposes. But civilians must be given ample time to flee, and any attack must be proportional to the military objective — putting the burden on Israel to show it was a big enough military target to justify the siege against it.

A TRICKLE OF FUEL FOR AID WORKERS

Conditions in southern Gaza have been deteriorating as bombardment continues to level buildings. Residents say bread is scarce and supermarket shelves are bare. Families cook on wood fires for lack of fuel. Central electricity and running water have been out for weeks across Gaza.

After refusing to allow fuel into Gaza since the war’s start, saying it would be diverted to Hamas, Israeli defense officials early Wednesday let in some 24,000 liters (6,340 gallons).

The fuel will only be used for the U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees, known as UNRWA, to continue bringing limited supplies of food and medicine from Egypt for the more than 600,000 people sheltering in U.N.-run schools and other facilities in the south.

The fuel cannot be used for hospitals or to desalinate water, said Thomas White, UNRWA’s director in Gaza. The amount is the equivalent of “only 9% of what we need daily to sustain lifesaving activities,” he said.

The Palestinian telecom company Paltel, meanwhile, said it was relying on batteries to keep Gaza’ mobile and internet network running, and that it expected services to halt later Wednesday. Gaza has experienced three previous mass communication outages since the ground invasion.

LOOKING SOUTH

Israeli troops have extended their control across northern Gaza. Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said Wednesday the ground operation will eventually “include both the north and south. We will strike Hamas wherever it is.”

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu echoed the plans, saying Israel’s goal is “a complete victory over Hamas in the south and the return of our hostages.”

If Israeli troops move south, it is not clear where Gaza’s population can flee, as Egypt refuses to allow a mass transfer onto its soil.

AP

WESTERN PERSPECTIVE

Ukrainian group says more than 30,000 troops have died in Russia's invasion

A Ukrainian civic group said it has confirmed the deaths of nearly 25,000 Ukrainian soldiers since Russia's February 2022 invasion by using open sources, and puts the total toll at more than 30,000.

Kyiv treats its losses as a state secret and officials say disclosing the figure could harm its war effort. A report in August by the New York Times, citing anonymous U.S. officials, put the Ukrainian death toll at close to 70,000.

Writing in the Ukrainian journal Tyzhden, historian Yaroslav Tynchenko and volunteer Herman Shapovalenko said Shapovalenko's Book of Memory project had confirmed 24,500 combat and non-combat deaths using open sources.

The real figure was likely higher, they added, noting that many of the 15,000 troops listed as missing were likely dead.

Reuters could not independently verify the figures.

"Obviously, the 24,500 names are not the final number of dead (deceased), but by our assessment it is no less than 70%," the authors wrote. "That is, the real number of dead (deceased) in combat and non-combat situations is more than 30,000 people."

Applying a 1:3 ratio, the authors also estimated that up to 100,000 troops had been wounded.

A spokesman for Ukraine's defence ministry told Reuters he could not comment on the figures.

The Book of Memory project, which has tracked Ukraine's war dead since Russia's first invasion in 2014, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Tynchenko, in a message through his employer, the National Military History Museum of Ukraine, declined to comment on the article.

The article, published late on Tuesday, comes as Ukraine increasingly faces the prospect of fighting a long war with Russia.

Ukraine's top general wrote in the Economist earlier this month that the conflict was becoming static and attritional. A Ukrainian counteroffensive launched in June has made only incremental gains in the south and east.

The authors of the Tyzhden article said it was crucial to balance various estimates reported in Western media, which they described as given to "manipulation", with verifiable data.

"Should we talk about this topic in Ukraine during the war? We believe so, but only in terms of concrete data and open and trustworthy sources," they wrote.

Russia has also not disclosed the number of its war dead.

RUSSIAN PERSPECTIVE

West sees Ukraine conflict lasting five more years – media

A growing number of Western leaders have reportedly conceded that the Russia-Ukraine conflict may drag on for another five years, stuck in a “stalemate” that neither side is capable of shattering.

The crisis has already strained the West’s military capacity amid struggles to produce enough artillery shells, the magazine said, and the Israel-Hamas war creates further stress. 

“As time goes on, there will be trade-offs as certain key systems are diverted to Israel,” Mark Cancian, a senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, wrote last month. “A few systems that Ukraine needs for its counteroffensive may not be available in the numbers that Ukraine would like.”

Ukraine’s top general, Valery Zaluzhny, raised eyebrows when he told The Economist earlier this month that the conflict with Russia had reached a stalemate. Although officials in US President Joe Biden’s administration were troubled by Zaluzhny’s candor, they agreed with his assessment, the New York Times reported last week.

The Ukraine crisis has revealed how “meager” Western armories are, The Economist claimed. Even as the US ramps up its output of 155mm artillery shells, its production in 2025 will be lower than Russia’s in 2024, the magazine added. If the overlapping conflicts in Ukraine and Israel both drag on, Washington and its allies would be hard-pressed to cope with another crisis.

“If the war in Ukraine stays an open sore in Europe and the Middle East remains ablaze, the West will struggle gravely should another serious crisis erupt,” the outlet warned. “One risk is that adversaries simply capitalize on chaos elsewhere for their own ends. If America were bogged down in a Pacific war, for instance, Iran would surely feel more confident of getting away with a dash for nuclear weapons.”

The magazine called the situation a “new world disorder” and suggested that Russia and China see “opportunities” in the growing threats. “Even more worrying is the prospect of active collusion. European military planners give weight to the possibility that Russia might conduct menacing maneuvers during a crisis over Taiwan in order to divert American attention and tie down its allies, preventing them from lending a hand in Asia.”

Concentrations of crises have occurred in past eras, The Economist said, “but America and its allies cannot intervene as easily or cheaply as they once did.” That’s partly because the Ukraine crisis has “cemented” the partnership between Russia and China, and the two countries are working more closely together, according to the magazine.

Reuters/RT

Today is the 119th birthday of Nnamdi Azikiwe, Owelle-Osowa-Anya of Onicha, affectionately called Zik of Africa, a remarkable figure in Nigerian and African journalism and political history.

As the world marks Zik’s 119th posthumous birthday today, tribute must be paid to an iconic tall image who left an indelible mark on the nation’s sand of time.

Azikiwe's life and contributions as a journalist, politician and statesman are not only worthy of celebration but the story about Zik should be religiously told and transferred to generations unborn, in remembrance of a Great Icon.

He is among the central figures in the Nigerian independence struggle which earned him the title of the "father of Nigerian nationalism."

A Nigerian by all metrics. Zik, a full-blooded Igbo, from Onicha in Anambra State, was born in Zungeru, in today's Niger State on November 16, 1904, and died on 11 May 1996 at age 91, in Enugu State.

Zik’s father, Obed-Edom Chukwuemeka Azikiwe, was born in 1879 and died on March 3, 1958. His mother, Rachel Chinwe Ogbenyeanu Azikiwe, born in 1883, died two months before his father, in January 1958,

His father, Obed-Edom Chukwuemeka Azikiwe, was a clerk in the British Administration of Nigeria. He travelled extensively as part of his job.

Smart and intelligent young Zik got his early education at various mission schools, from Holy Trinity and Christ Church Schools in Onicha, to Hope Waddell Training College in Calabar, and then to Methodist Boys High School in Lagos.

Zik later travelled to the United States of America, where he earned degrees from several institutions, including Lincoln University in Pennsylvania.

Zik’s academic sojourn abroad was influenced by his teacher, James Aggrey, who believed that Africans should receive a college education abroad and return to effect change.

Zik’s academic experiences abroad exposed him to liberation struggles and Pan-Africanism, which later inspired his commitment to the struggle against colonialism and fight for independence, for a united Africa, at first and later Nigeria.

I am particularly in love with Zik’s life and contribution as a fearless and die-hard journalist and media investor. As a journalist, Zik invested his media prowess and intellectualism to propagate and advocate for social and political change in Africa and later Nigeria.

His depth and mastery of journalism qualified him to skillfully and oratorically express and convey the grievances and agitations of Nigerians against the colonial provocateurs, thereby earning him the respect and admiration of not only Nigerians but even the Colonial Merchants.

Zik began his journalism career as a columnist for the Baltimore Afro-American, Philadelphia Tribune, and the Associated Negro Press, in America.  He later moved to Gold Coast, presently Ghana, where he accepted an offer from Alfred Ocansey to become the founding editor of the African Morning Post, a daily newspaper in Accra. Zik was at liberty to run the newspaper and recruited many of its original staff.

Zik had a column known as "The Inside Stuff Zik", in which he preached radical nationalism and black pride which raised some alarm in colonial circles. As editor of the African Morning Post, Zik promoted a pro-African nationalist agenda.

He founded and edited several newspapers, including the "West African Pilot," which became a powerful tool for advocating for Nigerian independence and unity. Zik’s writings and editorials conveyed strong messages of self-determination and empowerment to the Nigerian people, earning him a reputation as a vocal and eloquent advocate for people’s rights.

As a politician, Zik was also fearless and resolute. He was a political enigma, a political mentor who understood the importance of making and empowering men. Little wonder there was a Zikist Movement, a group of political enthusiasts and activists that believed in Zik’s leadership and ideology.

As aforementioned, Zik’s role in the struggle for Nigerian independence was not limited to journalism. He teamed up with other nationalists across Nigeria in politics to fight for its independence and quickly rose through the ranks.

For Zik, “Leadership is not about the position one holds, but about the positive impact one has on others.” He also opined that “Leadership is the great unifier, the builder of nations, the spearhead of progress.”

Zik was aware that Nigeria’s diverse ethno-religious groups could derail every progressive nationalistic struggle for a better nation, and he insisted that “In diversity lies the strength of a nation, for it is in different perspectives that true progress is born.”

Zik was a man of words and honour with infectious oratory powers. Despite attaining higher heights in public service, he held tenaciously to the belief that “The true measure of a leader is not how they rise to power, but how they use that power to uplift others”, insisting also that “Leadership is not about the position one holds, but about the positive impact one has on others".

Zik was a member of the Nigerian Youth Movement (NYM), the country's first nationalist organisation. He later co-founded the National Council of Nigeria and the Cameroons (NCNC) with Herbert Macaulay in 1944.

It is instructive to note that Zik was the first President of the Nigerian Senate from January 1st, 1960 to 1 October 1960. On his 56th birthday on November 16, 1960, Zik assumed the role of Nigeria's Governor-General, marking a significant step towards self-governance for Nigeria. He was later appointed to the Privy Council of the United Kingdom. This appointment emphasized his influence on the global political stage.

When Nigeria transitioned to a Republic in 1963, Zik, a Pan-Nigeria, was inaugurated as Nigeria’s first President. His leadership at this critical juncture in Nigeria's history signified the realisation of long-held dreams for self-rule and sovereignty. Under his presidency, Nigeria made significant progress in building a strong foundation for the newly-established Republic.

His unwavering commitment to the cause of Nigerian nationalism earned him the title of "Father of Nigerian nationalism."

He played a pivotal role in uniting Nigeria's diverse ethnic groups and fostering a sense of national identity. His vision for a united, independent Nigeria was instrumental in shaping the nation's destiny.

An astute Pan-Nigerian, Zik could speak fluently the three major indigenous languages – Igbo, Hausa, and Yoruba. He exemplified the ideals of  detribalised Nigeria, statesmanship, leadership, and dedication to the betterment of Nigeria and the Black Race.

For me, nothing should be left out in celebrating the enduring impact of this Great Leader of all Time. He was an Iconic Tall Image, who helped paved the way for Nigeria's independence and continues to inspire future generations.

He remains a significant figure in Nigeria's history. It is, therefore, crucial to acknowledge the significant role he played in shaping Nigeria's destiny. His unwavering commitment to the independence struggle paved the way for future generations, instilling the values of unity, patriotism and leadership in Nigeria.

Therefore, I call on well-meaning Nigerians to join in celebrating and honouring the life and legacy of this Great remarkable statesman, the "father of Nigerian nationalism," whose contributions have left an indelible mark on Nigeria's history, reminding us of the power of determination and resilience in the pursuit of a better future.

To buttress the importance of Zik’s contributions to Nigeria, he appears to be the most immortalized and honoured Nigerian leader with several national monuments, like Nnamdi Azikiwe's portrait on  N500 note, the Nnamdi Azikiwe Airport, Abuja, and many roads and streets named after him across Nigeria.

There is no major city or town across Nigeria that does not have at least one road or street with the name Nnamdi Azikiwe. There is Azikiwe Road in Aba, Azikiwe Road in Umuahia all in Abia State, Zik Avenue, Onicha, and Zik Avenue Oka, all in Anambra State. There is also Nnamdi Azikiwe University (UniZik) Oka, Anambra State. Zik Avenue, Enugu State, Azikwe Road Port Harcourt, Nnamdi Azikwe Express Way, Abuja, Nnamdi Azikwe Street, Lagos, Nnamdi Azikiwe Street, Kaduna, Nnamdi Azikiwe Library, University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Nnamdi Azikiwe Stadium in Enugu; Nnamdi Azikiwe University Teaching Hospital, Nnewi; Nnamdi Azikiwe Press Centre, Dodan Barracks, Lagos; Azikiwe Avenue in Dar-es-Salam, Tanzania among others.

Zik was a lover of sports. He participated in boxing, athletics, football and tennis competitions. He later founded Zik’s Athletic Club (ZAC), to encourage sport-related activities for lovers of sports in Nigeria.

Let's celebrate Zik.

Happy 119th posthumous birthday, Nnamdi Azikiwe!

Happy 119th posthumous birthday, Owelle-Osowa-Anya of Onicha!

Happy 119th posthumous birthday, Zik of Africa!

** Enyinnaya Appolos, a journalist, writes from Abuja.

In the world of mental health, “dysmorphia” describes an obsessive focus on perceived defects in one’s body. People with body dysmorphic disorder may find themselves constantly comparing themselves unfavorably with the appearance of others.

Ali Katz, an estate lawyer and founder of the Family Wealth Planning Institute, sees an analogous phenomenon in the world of financial psychology — a state in which someone’s self-perception regarding their money doesn’t match reality.

She calls it “money dysmorphia.”

“It’s a distorted view that we have around money that causes us to make poor decisions,” Katz says.

One common form Katz sees among her clients is the belief that they’re not wealthy enough to make important plans for their assets. But that’s a bit of faulty and potentially damaging thinking, she says. 

“The way this plays into estate planning or investing is we don’t do it. We’re not rich enough to do estate planning. I’m not wealthy, I’m not rich,” Katz says. “But it’s absolutely untrue.”

An estate plan should be a ‘rite of passage’

One thing Katz hopes Americans can keep in mind is that, in the scope of the whole world, they’re wealthy. Some 62% of the world population lives on less than $10 a day, and 85% live on less than $30, according to the World Economic Forum.

“We’re so wealthy, we’re so rich comparatively, but then of course we’re comparing ourselves to Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk,” Katz says.

In other words, while you may not be a billionaire, or even have the kind of life you see people living on social media, you likely have assets in the form of cash, investing accounts or treasured belongings — and what you choose to do with them is important.

That’s where an estate plan comes in. A suite of estate planning documents, which often includes a will, a health-care directive, and financial and health-care powers of attorney. A will designates how you want your assets to be distributed in the case of your death. The other documents indicate your wishes for how your health care and financials will be handled if you become incapacitated.

“As soon as you turn 18 years old, you become an adult in the eyes of the law, specifically for the purposes of making your own health care and financial and legal decisions,” says Katz. “What that means is, the day you turn 18, if you have specific desires about how legal, financial or health-care decisions would be made for you, it’s time to step into adulthood.”

As a young person, it may not feel like you have an estate, or that you’ll ever need these documents. But if you don’t indicate what you want in these scenarios, the state, generally, makes decisions for you. Should you die without children, for example, the law typically states that your assets go to your parents. If that’s not what you’d prefer, it’s important to make that clear.

“The way I look at it, the creation of these documents — who you’re going to name, telling them what you want — is a rite of passage. An initiation,” says Katz.

You don’t have to be wealthy to invest, either

Financial pros see a similar line of thinking among young people who think the investing is something that’s reserved for the wealthy.

This notion is a “toxic” money mindset, Ramit Sethi a self-made millionaire and star of the Netflix show “How to Get Rich,” previously told CNBC Make It.

In fact, it’s completely backward, he says. “The way you get wealthy is by investing.”

Sethi knows that it can feel difficult to earmark money for a goal decades away when your present-day budget is stretched. That’s why he advocates for automatic transfers from your paycheck into an investing account, so that the money is out of sight, out of mind and working for your future.

“You can often change your entire socioeconomic trajectory for yourself and your family by starting this one simple thing, which is automatically investing,” he says. “That gets me excited because it means you can actually start to live a rich life, not worry about money for the next 20 years.”

The key to Sethi’s calculus is compounding interest, which allows a consistent investor to grow even very modest contributions into large sums of money over long periods of time. “Even if you can only invest $20 a month — that’s how you get started,” Sethi says.

Say that’s all you ever invested — $20 a month between age 20 and age 67. Over the course of your life as an investor, you will have put away more than $11,000.

But use Make It’s compound interest calculator to see how long-term, methodical investing can grow that money. If you earned an 8% annualized return on your investment, for instance, you’d end up with about $125,000.

CNBC

Nigerian Labour Congress, NLC, and Trade Union Congress of Nigeria, TUC, nationwide strike recorded mixed compliance across the states, yesterday. While some states were shut down with banks, public schools, courts and others shut down, some states recorded partial compliance and a few did not comply.

The directives of the two labour bodies were carried out in Lagos, Anambra, Abia, Ebonyi, Kebbi, and Edo among others.

In Kano, banks and schools were shut as the government suspended qualifying examinations. Also schools were shut in Osogbo, the Osun State capital with the police beefing up security to avoid breakdown of law and order

In Imo, there was partial compliance as banks opened for business.

However, workers shunned the industrial action in Enugu and Abuja, with Labour leaders saying they would ensure strike in the Federal Capital Territory, FCT, today.

The two unions in the nation’s public universities disagreed over the strike. While the Academic Staff Union of Universities, ASUU, asked its members to join the strike, the Congress of University Academics, CONUA, directed its members to shun the action.

This is coming as the Organised Labour pooh-poohed claims by the Special Adviser to President Bola Tinubu on Information and Strategy, Bayo Onanuga, that the ongoing nationwide strike was an ego trip intended to ‘blackmail the government.’ It insisted that the strike was not a personal matter affecting the NLC President, Joe Ajaero, as alleged.

On November 13, 2023, the National Executive Council, NEC, meeting of the labour unions, in Abuja, resolved to embark on the strike due to the alleged failure of the Federal Government to address issues affecting workers such as the minimum wage, insecurity, corruption, and poor governance.

Also, both unions said they had made some demands, which the government allegedly failed to address following the recent crisis in Imo that resulted in the brutalisation of Ajaero, and other members of the labour unions.

Apart from the brutalisation of Ajaero, other labour leaders, and journalists, other grievances of Organized Labour include outstanding salary arrears, unjust declaration of 11,000 workers as ghost employees, unsettled gratuities, non-compliance of N30,000 minimum wage act, and declaration of 10,000 pensioners as ghost retirees.

The Federal Government on November 13 warned both unions against embarking on their planned strike, saying it would amount to contempt of court.

Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Lateef Fagbemi, in a statement, said the government had obtained a restraining order from the National Industrial Court of Nigeria barring the unions from going ahead with the strike.

Labour leaders expressed satisfaction with the level of compliance on Day One, noting that the compliance level would be much better in the coming days.

As of yesterday among the major critical sectors that fully complied with the strike were workers in the Maritime sector who shut the Ports formations in Lagos, Rivers, Cross River and Delta states.

The Maritime Workers Union of Nigeria, MWUN in compliance with the Labour directive, shutdown port operations at Apapa and Tin-can Island.

This is even as freight forwarders have called on the Minister of Marine and Blue Economy as well as the management of the Nigerian Shippers Council, NSC to ensure that terminal operators and shipping lines do not slam demurrage on them for the duration of the strike.

Similarly, workers in the Food, Beverage and Tobacco, Chemical and Non-metallic Products and the Construction sectors, fully complied.

PENGASSAN joins

The Petroleum and Natural Gas Senior Staff Association of Nigeria, PENGASSAN, directed its members nationwide to join the industrial action via a circular by its General Secretary, Lumumba Okungbowa.

Speaking on the Day One of the strike, Deputy President of TUC, Tommy Okon, said: “We are very happy about the level of compliance so far. Many workers received the notice from their unions very late yesterday (Monday). I can authoritatively tell you there will be 100 percent compliance in the coming days.”

No meeting with FG – TUC

Meanwhile, the President of TUC, Festus Osifo, has dismissed reports of any meeting with the Federal Government, saying “I have no knowledge of any meeting with the government for now.”

Banks, trains grounded as Lagos workers join strike

However, the strike recorded an impact in Lagos as banks and train service were grounded.

The Secretary General, Nigeria Union of Railway Workers, Segun Esan, told newsmen that the union was involved in the strike and no train was running as a result.

“In effect, therefore, all the workers of Nigerian Railway are duty-bound to join the nationwide strike action from zero-zero hour of Tuesday, 14th November, 2023 by staying back at home and away from their offices.

“All the offices, stations, workshops, and entire premises of the corporation remain locked and inaccessible from zero-zero hour of Tuesday, 14th November, 2023, till otherwise directed by the Congress,” Esan said.

Also, the President of the Association of Senior Staff of Banks, Insurance, and Financial Institutions, Oluwole Olusoji, said advice had been sent out to members on compliance, adding that members had been advised to ensure the safeguard of lives and property from people who might be used to take undue advantage of the situation.

“We will continue to monitor the situation as it unfolds,” Olusoji said.

Join nationwide strike, ASUU directs members

The Academic Staff Union of Universities, ASUU wrote to all zonal coordinators and chairpersons of the union and directed them to mobilise members be mobilised for the strike in line with the NLC and TUC directives.

The letter which was signed by ASUU’s National President, Emmanuel Osodeke, was issued on Monday night.

The letter read in part:  “As an affiliate of NLC, all members of our union are hereby directed to join this action of NLC to protect the interest of Nigerian workers and the leadership of the union. Zonal coordinators and branch chairpersons should immediately mobilise our members to participate in the action. A people united, cannot be defeated.”

Don’t join strike, CONUA directs members

Conversely, CONUA directed its members not to join the strike.

In a statement by its President, Niyi Sumonu, CONUA stated that the academic union was not communicated on the strike directive by the TUC which it sought to be an affiliate, noting that processes to become an affiliate of the TUC were yet to be completed, and the TUC had failed to communicate it on the directive to embark on strike.

“As at the moment of putting together this release, the TUC with whom CONUA submitted an affiliation request has not communicated this position on strike action to it. Distinguished comrades should therefore note that CONUA cannot be part of the strike action that is not communicated to it. In addition, the affiliation process with the TUC has not been officially established,” the statement read in part.

Public schools shut in Osogbo, police beef up security

Meanwhile, some public schools in Osogbo, Osun State, shut down operations in compliance with the strike directive, yesterday morning.

The students that had resumed at their various schools in the town were at about 9 am seen on the streets around Stadium, Ayetoro and West Bye-pass, Osogbo returning home.

During a visit to some schools within the metropolis, teachers were seen in their various offices after the students had been sent home.

Some of the schools visited include Fakunle High School, Osogbo, Saint James Grammar School and Adenle Grammar School also located in Ayetoro Area, Osogbo.

None of the teachers who were approached agreed to comment on record.

A few of them who spoke said they had resumed work only to be told of the commencement of strike by labour leaders.

‘’We couldn’t hold back the students when the labour leaders came around and asked us to shut down operations. The students have been released but many teachers are still around the premises,” a male teacher told  Vanguard.

Contacted, Osun NLC acting chairperson, Modupe Oyedele, said workers in the state complied fully with the strike directive, adding “Osun is in full compliance with the strike directive.”

Unusual presence of armed police operatives was observed at some strategic points in Osogbo in an apparent move to prevent a breakdown of law and order.

Police operatives were stationed at Lameco Junction, Old Garage and Olaiya areas of Osogbo. Economic activities were going on without hitches in the areas visited.

Banks, schools shut in Kano, govt suspends qualifying exams

In Kano, Primary and secondary schools, as well as tertiary institutions, joined the strike.

Primary and day secondary school pupils who went to school as early as 7.30 am were compelled to return home as they did not meet teachers in the schools.

The strike also affected operations in banks, hospitals, and other public places in the state.

Similarly, the Audu Bako State Secretariat, which houses most of the ministries, was closed even though some workers who were not aware of the strike reported for work in the morning but had to return home later.

Students in Bayero University Kano who are currently sitting for their first semester examinations were also affected by the strike as a number of them who went to the examination halls had to return to their respective hostels.

“Many students who were to sit for exams in the morning returned to their hostels disappointed because they could not see anybody in the examination halls,” a female student said.

Consequently, the Kano State Ministry of Education has suspended the 2023 Secondary Schools Qualifying Examination scheduled to take place today, until further notice.

A statement signed by the Director of Public Enlightenment of the Ministry, Balarabe Kiru, revealed that the suspension is compelled by the industrial action embarked upon by the NLC and TUC nationwide.

Workers defy directives, continue work in Abuja

However,  federal and private sector workers in Abuja all resumed their duty posts, yesterday morning, in defiance to the strike directives.

All offices at the Federal Secretariat,Abuja,were opened for work just as activities in and around the secretariat were in full swing.

There was no sign that any worker was absent from work on account of the strike.

At the Federal Ministry of Education, the Minister, Prof. Tahir Mamman, performed his activities as scheduled. In fact, he presided over the Pre-departure briefing of the 179 Bilateral Education Agreement, BEA, Scholars, who were awarded Russian scholarships for the 2023/2024 academic session.

At the Federal Ministry of Health, all workers were seen at work. The Minister, Prof. Ali Pate, Permanent Secretary, Kachollom Daju, and other senior staff of the ministry were at work when Vanguard visited.

A worker who pleaded anonymity, said he came because he was yet to be directed to stay off duty by labour leaders in the health sector.

“I would have complied if I had a directive to that effect by the labour leaders of our local branch. We can’t stay at home because we read on the pages of newspapers that NLC and TUC have declared strike. If the directive to that effect comes today, then you may not see me on duty tomorrow,” he said.

The same thing was observed at the Federal Ministry of Humanitarian Affairs. All workers in the ministry were on duty. Although the Minister, Betta Edu, was yet to come to her office when  Vanguard  visited.

Workers who spoke, said although they cited the circular from the national secretariat of NLC directing that they stay off duty, they couldn’t obey since their local chapter did not act on the correspondence.

Some labour leaders were seen hanging around the Federal Secretariat discussing the strike issue and their next strategies to effect the directives of the national leadership of their unions.

Asked to speak on the ineffective strike directives, one of the labour leaders told  Vanguard  in confidence that they would affect the strike today.

Just like the federal government workers, private sector workers were seen in their various places of work.

Also banks located in and around the Federal Secretariat were all opened to business. Staff and customers were seen transacting business.

Businesses went on around the Federal Secretariat complex.

NLC,TUC, affiliates shutdown Kebbi

In Kebbi, economic activities were grounded and public offices were closed.

Kebbi State Chairman of NLC, comrade Murtala Usman, told newsmen that they joined the industrial action because the “Organised Labour is a family, therefore an injury to one is an injury to all hence our reason to halt economic activities in Kebbi State to ensure that justice is done to our amiable leader, Mr. Ajearo who was unjustly manhandled by suspected security agencies for pressing demands of workers in Imo State.”

He added all labour affiliates like National Association of Nigerian Nurses and Midwives, NANNM; judiciary Staff Union, JUSUN, and all other unions had complied with directive shutting offices and social facilities.

“Kebbi State remains shut till further directives from our mother union to do otherwise. So, I urge Nigerians and the people of the state to cooperate with us as we struggle to ensure demands of Nigerians are met.”

NLC paralyses activities in Edo, shut down public offices, others

The strike  recorded a huge success in Benin City, the Edo State capital as public schools, government offices, courts, some banks and other public places like the National Museum, the House of Assembly complex and others were shut by officials of the NLC.

Litigants were stranded at the entrance gates to the High Court Complex while some personnel did not also open the judges’ gates through which High Court judges enter their offices.

A lawyer, Afolabi Olayiwola, who couldn’t access the court premises said the strike was a sign of a failed system.

He expressed shock that despite a court order stopping the strike, judiciary workers still embarked on the strike.

“Ordinarily, the strike ought not to have been because there is a court order and if judiciary staff cannot obey a court order it shows it is a failed system and if it escalates it becomes a problem. If other sectors go on strike the judiciary arm ought not to have embarked on it as they are aware of the court order. That is where I am worried”

At the Benin Airport, an official said planes landed and took off and travellers were seen making their way into the airport to catch their flights to different destinations.

Banks along Akpakpava, Mission roads, Forestry and other areas were shut down with customers trying to get money from a few ATMs that dispensed cash.

Government schools in the GRA were shut as students were seen loitering around their schools.

A security officer at NPDC said the staff were complying with the strike with only essential workers allowed into the premises.

Also, Oredo, Egor and other local government secretariats visited in Benin City complied with the strike as workers in their numbers hung around the councils’ premises.

The Ambrose Alli University (AAU) Ekpoma, branch of ASUU directed its members to comply with the directives of the NLC. Checks by our correspondent showed that there were skeletal activities in the campus as the students were seen preparing for their Computer Based Tests (CBT) which was to start yesterday and various offices were opened for normal activities.

But the CONUA, University of Benin chapter, distanced itself from the strike, describing it as a “one man decision.”

Chairman of UNIBEN CONUA, Ishaq Osagie-Eweka, told journalists that CONUA is not an affiliate of the NLC, hence, it is not part of the protest. “I call on our members to go about their lawful duties for the overall best interest of the students.

“As a chapter, we shall not make any public statement regarding the sudden strike arising from one man’s decision, over his ill-conceived protest in Imo State that led to an alleged physical attack,” he said.

In Auchi, the headquarters of Etsako West LGA in Edo North, government offices and banks were closed to the public.

The closure of the State Secretariat was supervised by the chairman of Edo Chapter of the NLC, Odion Olaye with some workers and union executives seen within the complex, situated along Sapele Road, to ensure that members comply with the strike directives.

Also speaking, Comrade Alabi Precious, Chairman Edo State TUC Trade Union Congress said: “Our action was necessitated by the brutalization of the National President of NLC, Joe Ajaero and we are ready to get to the end of this matter.”

Ebonyi judiciary, university, banks shutdown

The Ebonyi State Judiciary, Federal University Ndufu-Alike Ikwo, FUNAI, Banks, and ministries in Abakaliki, were yesterday shut down for the nationwide strike.

There was 90 percent compliance to the strike, as many workers, including lawyers and bankers were stranded at the gate of the complex located at Water Works Road Abakaliki, the capital of Ebonyi State.

The strike also paralyzed business activities in the state, especially those who trade inside the court premises. Academic activities at FUNAI and Ebonyi State University, EBSU were affected by the strike.

Speaking to newsmen in Abakaliki, the state chairman of the NLC, Egwu Ogugua said: “So far so good, our compliance to the strike is 90 percent, the Ochi-Udo secretariat is scanty, the Ebonyi judiciary is under lock and key, the banks are not functioning. It’s only Zenith Bank that is open but they are not open to customers.

“What happened in Imo State, especially what is happening in Nigeria is bad. We have been pushed to the wall, we have been crushed. The ruling class no longer believes that we exist. It’s like anarchy has begun and that’s the situation we see ourselves in Nigeria,” he said.

Anambra workers comply with NLC directives

The chairman of the Anambra chapter of the NLC, Humphrey Nwafor, said workers in the state had already joined the strike as directed by the national body.

He said defaulters of the directives would be dealt with accordingly.

He said: “We’ve joined the strike. We’ve directed our members to stay away from their offices and workplaces till further notice. There won’t be any street protests. We’re only withdrawing our services as directed by the national body.”

Courts, schools under lock as NLC strike hits Abia

Also, the strike crippled activities in various courts and schools in Umuahia, Abia State capital.

The industrial action, which kicked off on Tuesday, 14th November, is to be enforced in all affiliate unions of the NLC in Abia, according to a press release signed by its Chairman, Pascal Nweke.

The Abia State High Court complex at Ikot Ekpene Road, Umuahia, and the High Court and Magistrate Courts inside the main buildings were under lock and key.

Lawyers, litigants, and judiciary staff were seen loitering outside the main gate.

Teachers in Primary school (1) School Road Primary School, Ibeku High School among other government schools also joined the strike.

Pupils of City Primary School at the school road were seen playing football during learning hours.

Staff of Nigerian Postal Service (NIPOST) Umuahia also joined the strike.

However, staff of some Abia State government establishments only observed a skeletal strike

Our Correspondent observed some civil servants entering the offices of the Head of Service, Secretary to Abia State Government, and the Michael Okpara auditorium, through one side of their gates, even though some offices remained locked.

Electricity workers supplied light to Umuahia city but withdrew the light by 11:10 am.

Also, most commercial banks in Umuahia were still rendering normal services to customers as of the time of this report, even though customers were only allowed into their premises in batches.

Enugu workers shun NLC, TUC strike directive, resume at duty posts

Workers in Enugu State defied the strike directive and resumed at their various duty posts.

In some areas of Enugu, the state capital, banks were observed rendering services to their customers. Workers of some government agencies also resumed work early in the morning.

At the government revenue office along Zik Avenue, workers were in their various offices, while a bank along Agbani Road was also rendering services to customers. Both private and government schools also did not observe the strike.

A civil servant, who spoke on condition of anonymity, blamed the leadership of both NLC and TUC over the non-compliance with the strike directive, saying they failed to act when the ovation was loudest.

There was heavy vehicular movement on the major roads of Enugu city while the markets were open for businesses.

Imo workers comply partially, banks open for businesses

In Imo State, the strike recorded a partial compliance as civil servants reported for duty and banks opened for businesses.

Gates to the state secretariat were wide opened for workers.

Several workers were seen at their various duty posts discussing the outcome of the governorship election which was won by Governor Hope Uzodimma for another four-year term.

However, many of the workers reported out of fear as some registered their names and left very early for their homes.

Many banks in the state attended to their customers

Some courts complied with the strike directive but some litigants who were not aware of the strike came to the court to hear their cases.

At Douglas Road, Wetheral Road, and Bank Road, people were seen transacting businesses in the banks.

However, at some of the federal establishments such as Federal University of Technology Owerri (FUTO) and Federal Polytechnic Nekede, Owerri, workers stayed away from their offices, saying, “we are on strike.”

Brutalisation of Ajaero not a personal matter—Labour

Faulting Onanuga’s comment that the strike was an ego trip because of Ajaero, the NLC, in a statement, by its Head of Information and Public Affairs, Benson Upah, titled “Bayo Onanuga’s mischief and the tragedy of a nation”, said Onanuga is suffering from selective amnesia.

Why insisting the strike is not a personal matter affecting Ajaero, as alleged, the NLC urged Nigerians to ignore the Special Adviser to the President on Information and Strategy, because he is known for his overzealous hirelings with the mistaken belief that would earn him the confidence of his principal.

The statement read in part: “If Onanuga were not suffering from selective amnesia, he ought to have known that this government should remain grateful to the organised labour for its uncommon patience with a government that clearly was not prepared for the consequences of its fundamentalist market policies of massive currency devaluation and ‘subsidy’ removal which imposed on Nigerians social violence, upheaval, dislocation, displacement or punishment they never before experienced.

“Onanuga, similarly ought to have known that organised labour, by not opting for a strike as a first option, acted as a bulwark against the rage of Nigerians thereby saving this government from itself.

“Organised labour is not unaware of the misdirected anger of Nigerians for not going for the jugular of this government for justifiable reasons: inflation moved from 19 percent to 29 percent; exchange rate from N400 to N1,300; and pump price of Petrol from N187 to N700, in the first five months of this government!

“In light of this, who is punishing “a whole country of over 200 million people”, NLC/TUC or the Government of Bola Tinubu?

“Similarly, this strike is not ‘over a personal matter involving the NLC President, Mr Joe Ajaero, whose error of judgment led to the assault on him in Owerri while he was planning to incite the workers in Imo State into a needless strike’, as casually and callously alleged by Bayo Onanuga.

“However, herein lies the kernel of the matter. Mr Ajaero is General Secretary of National Union of Electricity Employees, NUEE, and neither he nor any of the members of his union in or outside Imo State is owed a salary/pension payment arrears.

“However, in his capacity as President of the Nigeria Labour Congress he has an oversight over all the unions affiliated to the Congress including the civil servants and pensioners (core/non-core civil servants, teachers, local government workers, pensioners etc) who have been owed in varying degrees of arrears.

“There have been pending cases of improper implementation of national minimum wage, declaration of thousands of workers as ghost workers, and non-implementation of agreements reached with the state government since 2021.

“Some of this went to court and the state government asked for time out of court for settlement but did not honour its own voluntary agreement as usual. The state government in a written statement did admit it was too busy working to honour its own voluntary agreement.

“A previous strike action was suspended on the appeal of elder statesmen and women and an appeal by the state government. After this, Congress made every humanly possible effort to have the issues peacefully resolved, all to no avail. Congress was left with no option than to resume a strike action in the state with notice. Congress had been to a couple of other states that did not even commit the sins of the Imo State Government.

“Coupled with the above, fresh demands were made following the abduction, and gruesome assault and battery òf Comrade Joe Ajaero (by the Police) out of which none has been met fully.

“How then could this be a personal matter to Joe Ajaero? Before he became Congress President, he never bothered himself with the affairs of Imo State or any state for that matter except it was the decision of Congress organs.”

Vanguard